But she still has not stopped sabotaging Fabina when Joy talked to her teacher Mrs.Valentine, Mrs.Valentine gives Joy advice that she should figure out what the root of her problem is with herself and Fabian and then get rid of it. Joy figured that Nina was the problem so she posted an article about Nina. The article says NIna keeps on skipping class to go and see her ill grandmother at the hospital which did not help but made it worse with Fabian and Joy. Fabian said Joy was not the girl he used to know and when he walked away Joy said he was not the boy she used to know.
After feeling horrible for what she did she slowly starts to turn away from Patricia. Joy and Patricia get into a fight about what's been going on. Joy says she doesn't need Patricia and Patricia says she will lose her friends. After Nina falls down the the Senet board, Fabian turns to Joy, to Amber's dismay. Fabian tells Joy about Sibuna and she gets all excited. Amber believes she will mess up the game so they never find Nina, which hurts Joys feelings. She said she would play chess all the time when she was locked up in season 1. She becomes very good at Senet, but takes a long time to learn it. She sucessfully gets Fabian across the board, and they make up as friends. In the season 2 finale, Joy and Fabian dance together. She is happy when Fabian and Nina get back together.